Idol Thoughts "Off Season Update"

Check out the latest Podcast and stay up to date with Idol, including Kelly Clarkson's latest tour information and a look at other Idol contestants run up the charts!

Idol Thoughts:Season Six Finale!

There is a new podcast about the Finale Listed Below:

http://idolthoughts.mypodcast.com/index.html

Hope everyone has a safe and sober Memorial Day Weekend!!!

Top 3: Who Will Make the Final?

Well, after a good vacation we're back to blog for tonight's show, The Top Three. Podcasts will return tomorrow. Onto the business at hand. Blake, Melinda and Jordin, an interesting mix for this season, amazing that Sanjaya held out as long as he did. A selection of three tonight. One from the judges, one from the producers, and one from the contestants.
Jordin up first, "Wishing on a Star," solid start, love the dress. Great start to the night. Judges: Randy, that was a very good vocal, Paula, Simon picked a good song for you, Simon, sang it brilliantly, didn't like the jazz arrangement. Blake coming up and it's gonna be a long hour...
Blake, "Roxanne," I've never been a big fan of the echo effect on the mic for any of the performances this year. Blake is doing a good job but he sounds too much like the original to me. Judges: Randy, liked the whole thing, pretty good vocal, Paula, you did me pround, Simon, not going to call that earthshattering, always forced to do an impersonation.
Melinda next. "I Believe in You and Me," nice to see Mel slowing it down, but again comparisons to Whitney. It was good to hear her voice on the song. She did a great job. Judges: Randy, that was hot, Paula, you were fantastic, Simon, very very difficult, your best performance of the last four weeks, Round 1 goes to Melinda.
Round 2 is coming up. Two of the three performances were solid, but did not defer that much from the original versions of the songs. This disappointed me a little.
Producers choices up next...Jordin, "Hard for the Money,"..solid opening, great song choice for her vocal range. Paula and Randy liked it, Simon thought it was a tad hokey.
Blake, "This Love," solid start, and a good song for Blake, he as a voice similar to Adam from Maroon 5, he did a good job with it. Judges: Randy, very nicely done, Paula, its a good night for you, Simon, I preferred that one to the first one, sounded comfortable, not copycat. Producers choice for Mel coming up...
Melinda, "Tina Turner", an odd choice for Melinda. Not so sure I liked that song. She did a good job with the song though and the judges agreed. Jordin and Blake on the way...Jordin, "I Who Have Nothing," Jordin is showing herself as very poised tonight. She is ready for the Finals. Judges: Randy, best performance of the night, Paula, good choice, Simon, hated the fact that a 17 year old was singing a 60 year old song. Blake, "When I Get You Alone," nice song choice for Blake to close out the night. Very smooth vocals tonight. Judges: Randy, it was cool, Paula, three great performances, Simon, I actually really liked that. Melinda closes the show....
Mel, with that performance she has a place in the finals according to Simon....recap in a few

Stayin' Alive Without Fallin' Asleep

The night overall lacked an energy. The top performers of the night were Melinda and Jordin. Jordin's best performance of the season may have been tonight, "To Love Somebody".
Blake totally missed the mark with, "This is Where I Came In". Lakisha too had some issues with her songs tonight. It seemed like the toll of the season is getting to everyone. The bottom two(since three at this point isn't really fair). I agree with Simon in that it's Blake and Lakisha.
Since I won't get to a podcast for the wrap this week due to travel, I feel that Blake will be headed home tomorrow night, which will leave three ladies to battle it out for the title of Idol 2007.
Enjoy the week, we'll be back on Monday with a written preview for the Top Three with the podcast returning after the vote for next week's show.

Top 4: Barry Gibb, Vocal Coach

Wel, it's the BeeGees Night on Idol....two performances for each contestant...up first Melinda, "Love You Inside Out"...strong start to the night, loved the bridge..another solid start from Mel...Judges: Randy is yeah or nay, Paula can't figure out what to say, Simon said it was a backup singers performance, which is pretty dead on....
Up next, Blake, "You Should Be Dancing", kinda strange for Blake, the song never really took off. Judges: Randy, didn't like the beatboxing, Paula didn't like it, Simon, terrible. Not the best from Blake and playing with three women he should know better.
Third of the night, Lakisha, "Stayin Alive", she slowed it down.....interesting...vocal was solid, not sure I like what she did with the song. Judges: Randy, not impressed, Paula, thought it was a downer, Simon, verging on scary.
Jordin up next..."To Love Somebody," she was very comfortable on stage, the best performance of the night so far, and the judges agree. After the first four the Bee Gees are putting me to sleep.
Round 2 starting with Melinda. "How Can You Mend a Broken Heart," solid vocal, another master class, the second half was impeccable. Judges: Randy, much better, Paula, liked it, Simon, the second half should put you into the semi finals.
Blake up next, "This is Where I Came In", like the techno beat on the song, vocal is solid, but I personally don't know the song. I'm not sure that was the best song choice for Blake going into the Top Three next week. Judges: Randy, better than the last one, Paula, sang spot on key, Simon, don't know what that song was. I think Blake may be out tomorrow night. Lakisha up for seconds...
Lakisha, "Run to Me," good start for Lakisha on Round 2, nice to hear her voice, as opposed to the screaming in past weeks. Solid from Lakisha, liked the little squeak at the end. Judges: Randy, that was good, Paula, your still a champ, Simon, I think you and Blake are vulnerable tonight. Jordin up last, with not a lot of time for her.
Jordin, "Woman in Love," love the dress, she' s singing with the emotion in every word, she definitely did justice to that song...Babs would be proud. Judges: Randy, it was pitchy, Paula, I Love You Anyway, Simon, it was pageanty.
The recap in a few...not a great night on Idol, these guys and gals had great song to choose from. Barry Gibb, a legend in his own right and it missed.

Bon Jovi Night: Good Days, Bad Days, and NICE Days...

The night started and ended with a bang. Phil got the night started, Blake was amazingly original, and Melinda was vocally on par for the best performance of the night, Jordin did her best with what vocal ability she had, Chris had a little urban vibe going and Lakisha rebounded from last week, but will it be enough to keep her around for another week.
My bottom three, Chris, Lakisha, and Jordin. One will be safe and we will lose two tomorrow night. It is the point in the season where fairness takes a back seat to ability and you have to do your best every week, regardless of the theme and it may shock someone tomorrow night.
Who is headed home, the podcast will be up soon.

Bon Jovi Night: Top 5

Well, after a close call and might I say ratings saver, no one was voted off last week during "Idol Gives Back", which means more singing of Bon Jovi or Bon Jovi inspired tunes tonight...and off we go...
Up first, Phil, "Blaze of Glory", well he sounded good in the vignette. Phil starting out in the crowd with a great tune. Seems very poised tonight. One of the better performances of this season, nice to hear Phil's voice in his range. Judges: Randy, other than country week, your best performance on the show, Paula, you were living your inner kid up there, best opening we've had all season long, Simon, thought it was okay, didn't hear any authenticity, don't think you've done enough to last till next week. Phil did great and has enough fans now to pull him through next week, I think.
Looking forward to lots of filler tonight, with six performances and lots of extra time.
Jordin up next, "Livin' on a Prayer," Jordin has that total Pat Benatar rocker look on stage, but a little taller of course...she's trying to bring some emotion to the song, she would be doing a lot better moving around the stage and playing off the crowd, she tried to pull it together for the close. Judges: Randy, the verses were rough, wasn't your best, Paula, went for it knowing it was out of your range, Simon, it was like something out of the Adams Family, the singing was out of control, verging on shrieking at times, it was terrible.
Lakisha up next, and this may very well be her swan song. "This Ain't a Love Song," she's started well, looking for the big voice to show up, this is one of Bon Jovi's hit songs, but it's not as big as some of the others, the only problem is it's repetitive. She did a great job with it.
Judges: Randy, she's back this week, Paula, you did give everyone a little somethin somethin, Simon, I could kiss you after that. (and she did). Blake up next.
Blake, "You Give Love a Bad Name," I sense some beat boxing tonight...interesting start, I liked it...like the beat for the song..Blake sounds good, seens pretty comfortable, and he's kept with the main part of the song. He's totally put HIS personality into the song and I think he pulled it off. Judges: Randy, the award for the most original of a song ever on American Idol, that was hot, Paula, the biggest leap of faith, this was amazing, Simon, that was the right thing to do, took a massive risk, this is what is going to keep you in the competition this week.
A wow for Blake, that was awesome!
Chris next..."Wanted: Dead or Alive," Chris seems to have a Garth Brooks look in his eye tonight, he's doing okay, but the tune isn't really doing much for me, unfortunately. He didn't do anything really to make it his own, the complete opposite of Blake, which may send him home.
Judges: Randy, did your thing, liked it, Paula, turning out to be a great night, Simon, did as much as he could do. Melinda closes the show...."Have a Nice Day," well, it sounds like yet another vocal schooling from Melinda....and it is! Nice to hear a female vocal on this song, she's bringing some soul to this song. She's like a mini Tina Turner, nice job from Melinda. Judges: Randy, a great performance, liked the Tina Turner attitude, Paula, you were singing your heart out, your a rock star!, Simon, thought it was like a young Tina Turner, in a different league tonight.
Recap of the evening coming in a few....

Rockin' Out on Idol

Well, just a few minutes away to Bon Jovi night on Idol....I think Lakisha is really in trouble this week, regardless of song...we'll find out in a few minutes.....

Idol Gives Back: Emotion, Another Master Class and A So-So Fantasia Impression

Idol Gives Back kicked off tonight on Idol, with some great heartwarming looks at poverty in Africa and here in the States. The performances were inspirational, emotional and heartfelt. It was a great start to the night from Chris and it ramped up to the close of the season from Jordin and possibly the best performances ever on the show.

So, who is in the bottom three. After some great performances and down to six, it’s going to be tough to find a bottom three. Lakisha will be there this week for reasons explained and she did a song that is too fresh in the minds of fans of Fantasia. Big big mistake on that song. The other two…although Phil did a great job tonight and is starting to get some praise, I am afraid it may be too little too late for Phil, the other girls will be safe so that leaves either Blake or Chris. Blake was solid on “Imagine” and has built up more of a fan base over the past weeks than Chris, which should put Chris in the bottom three with Lakisha and Phil this week. Who is headed home? Be sure to listen to the podcast shortly…

Idol Gives Back Performances(Top 6)

Well it’s a night of hope and compassion with Idol Gives Back. Bono is mentor, should be a fun evening. Nice piece to open the show with Coldplay’s “Trouble”. Tonight with two numbers per contestant. Chris Richardson up first

Chris, “Change the World,” good use of his vocal range, he’s put in some of his personality, nice start to the night. He’s very comfortable, nice job. Liked the rise at the end…Judges: Randy, for the first time in a long time, that was great, Paula, you did fantastic, great song choice, Simon, kinda feels like the competition starts tonight, good vocal, more soul in it, did really well. Melinda up next.

Melinda, “There Will Come a Day,” once again, a master class from Melinda in the period of a few minutes. The band did a great arrangement. Nice to hear an urban vibe to a Faith Hill song. Judges: Randy, you have arrived, Melinda is here, Paula, there’s no one like you, your magical, Simon, it wasn’t a copycat performance, it really was a vocal master class. Blake up next.

Blake, “Imagine,” …my girlfriend just put a magazine over the screen so I don’t know if I’ll be typing correctly…forgive me if anything doesn’t quite look right from this point on…Blake has a cool look going into the song tonight. He kept to the standards of the song and did a nice job with the song. It’s a night of compassion, so do I dare say Blake played it safe…no, but I can think it. Judges: Randy, great choice of song, performance was alright for me, Paula, first real sensitive performance from you, enjoyed it, Simon, felt sincere, didn’t go anywhere, you sang it with sincerity. I agree with Simon, Blake picked a BIG and very well known song and its hard to do anything unique with that.

Lakisha up next, “I Believe”, from Fantasia, she started out well, it’s tough to not compare her to the original. I think Lakisha is in trouble this week. Judges: Randy, had some pitch problems, did like it, Paula, a powerhouse of a vocalist, hard time comparing it to Fantasia, Simon, it was very emotional, having an issue with the shouting.

I think Lakisha is in trouble of heading home this week. She’s been playing it safe for a few weeks now and I think it’s going to catch up to her.

Phil next, which means Jordin closes the show.

Phil, “The Change,” going for some Garth Brooks. It’s nice to hear Phil in his lower range, I think this is where he is at his best vocally. He’s comfortable and singing with some emotion tonight. Nice job from Phil, but is it enough? Judges: Randy, since last week your back again this week, nice vocal, Paula, feel like you’ve found your comfort, this was your best, Simon, I really like you, came back with confidence, good choice of song.

Jordin up next to close the show, “You’ll Never Walk Alone,” great vocal to start, liked the falsetto, she’s got some emotion in that voice tonight, solid vocal tonight, best of the night, nice close to the show. Judges: Randy, one of the best vocals ever on this show, in six seasons, Paula, picked an amazing song, very haunting, did a lovely job, Simon, well, unlike Randy I thought you were fantastic, brilliant.

A solid night by all tonight, but who is headed home…the wrap of the night in a few.

Judges Truth, Another Vocal Class and NOTHING to Talk About

Martina McBride brought Country to Idol, and it rubbed off on most of the contestants. I’m not quite sure what Sanjaya was doing, but he secured safety for Chris and Lakisha with his performance tonight. The belters were out in force, mainly Melinda, Jordin and Blake. Phil seemed the most comfortable and for the first time in a few weeks showed that he belonged in the competition for this long.
A great night of comfort for everyone, but again, Lakisha seems to be hurting herself with her song choices. Thoughts and prayers to students, friends, and Alums of Virginia Tech.
My bottom three: Lakisha, Chris, and Sanjaya.
Who’s headed home. Check the podcast, updated soon…

Country Night with Martina McBride(Top 7)

Martina McBride tonight on Idol, it’s Country night. Let’s get right to it…
Time for the Top 7. Phil up first with some Keith Urban…
Phil comes out to the stage looking very relaxed and sounding great..nice start to the evening..Wow, Phil is performing, like the crowd strolling too, he’s showing some personality…nice job…Judges: Randy, that was hot, really good, Paula, sound good from the beginning, Simon, you’ve only taken ten weeks, only time I’ve heard you and saw some personality. Phil is SAFE, I hope. He chose the right song, but people already have their favorites.
Jordin next…”Broken Wing,” nice job on the start, putting emotion in all the right parts, she’s not rushing the song, solid stage presence, very cool, calm and collected. Nice to hear the power of her voice, with some emotion. Wow….Judges: Randy, another great performance, Paula, you look gorgeous, did a fantastic job, Simon, I believe, based on that performance you can win American Idol.
Sanjaya, “Something to Talk About”…ok that was my second choice for him to John Denver….apparently Country means it’s bandana time…not sounding bad at the start, uh uh playing to the camera, but he seems to have a limited range, but he’s staying in his safe lower range..but he’s having a lot of fun up there. Judges: Randy, really karaoke, what are we doing up here, Paula, watching somebody who loves adversity, Simon, utterly horrendous, as bad as anything we’ve seen at the beginning. I agree with Simon, it’s time for the fun to be over.
Lakisha, “Jesus Take the Wheel,” oh, I’m supposed to be writing…sorry, almost fell asleep. Not a bad start, she’s got that great booming voice and she used it tonight, but I think Jordin did a better, more original job. Judges: Randy, had some pitch problems, but my favorite vocal, Paula, agrees with Randy, vocals were powered, sounded like she was shouting, Simon, it’s like eating a hamburger for breakfast, it doesn’t go together. Her and the song didn’t go together. That was the wrong choice of song for you.
Chris, “Mayberry,” solid stage presence, seems comfortable, sounds pitchy to me, he’s not fitting the mold of the song. Judges: didn’t feel any emotion, felt lost, Paula, the joy and love on stage didn’t come through, Simon, I heard was a very nondescript nasally, tinny vocal, it was insignificant.
Melinda up next..Blake closes the show…Blake is in a prime spot to take over as top vote getter for this week.
Melinda, “Trouble is a Woman”…well, she gets the sass award for the night. Very comfortable, very solid, great performance, she’s putting personality into it. Well, she blew Lakisha away, again. Judges: Randy, another solid performance from a resident pro, Paula, a girl who knows how to pick the right song, Simon, it was fantastic, it was a great choice of song, saw some Tina Turner going on, an attitude.
Blake up next…”When the Stars Go Blue,” showing some nice range getting into the song. Like the falsetto, he’s putting his own style on the song and keeping it Country. Another great performance from Blake. Judges: Randy, loved he picked the right song, love that you know who you are, Paula, kinda have the whole package, always fun to watch you, Simon, thought it was okay.
The wrap on Country night, in a few.

Sanjaya's Gonna Pull a Denver....

Haven't seen any of the pre stuff for this weeks show, but it wouldn't surprise me, as I said in the podcast, if Sanjaya pulls out a showstopper like John Denver's Thank God I'm a Country Boy, wears a cowboy hat and dances with Paula into the Top 6...I see Phil possibly working some Johnny Cash tonight and Lakisha will have some issues...just a prediction.
We'll see in about 45 mins! Be back then...

Country Week with Martina McBride

It's Country Week on Idol and What Will Sanjaya Do? I may have some insight on what will keep him in the competition. Check out the podcast to the right and we'll be back to blog the evening tomorrow!

Latin Flair, Channeling Gloria Estefan, and "The" Goatee?

I found it Latin Night to be a very entertaining night, however it should have been called, “Gloria Estefan” night. Melinda kicked off the evening with Michael Buble’s “Sway” which I thought was pretty good, and the evening ended with Sanjaya pulling off a Spanish tune and not sounding bad. Jordin, Haley, and Lakisha seemed to have the most fun with their performances. Jordin had the best female vocal of the night, with Blake taking it for the guys. I still feel Lakisha is playing it safe week after week. She just isn’t hitting it, which is why this week she makes it into the bottom three, along with Haley and Phil and, I think there is a possibility that Sanjaya may be safe for another week. Who’s headed home? A more complete breakdown in the podcast shortly….

Latin Night with J-Lo(Top 8)

Well, another round of Idol, here we go, Latin night with J-Lo…and as Jennifer says it’s about the ‘passion’…up first tonight, Melinda
Melinda, “Sway”, like the look, decent stage presence, like her little touches to the song, this girl can sing the Oscar Mayer theme and make it amazing, solid performance from Melinda tonight, like the band’s rendition to…Judges: Randy, another solid performance, Paula, very sultry, smooth, wasn’t one where you had to wow us, Simon, had to happen, didn’t like it, that song is all about personality, and you appeared older, was very lounge, cabaret, bit lazy, thinks she’s better than that….next, Lakisha
I find it interesting they put the two with the most potential ‘trouble’ up front and center. With Idol its all about strategy and where you sing, could one of these first two be at..dare I say…’risk’ tomorrow night?
Lakisha next…”Conga”…solid on the stage, keeping the tempo well, I like her voice on this song, it’s tough because everyone is going to compare it to Gloria. She did another ‘safe’ song…Judges: Randy, having fun, made it your own, that was hot, Paula, didn’t feel it as much as Randy, felt it was a safe Lakisha, Simon, not a singers song, a performance song, quite a safe song to do, the dancing wasn’t great….Lakisha may be in the bottom three this week. Chris next.
Chris Richardson, “Smooth”, oooh, ooh the Justin Timberlake version of “Smooth”, stage presence is okay, doesn’t seem original too me tonight…like the color of the guitar, that’s sweet! Had some nice vocals..Judges: Randy, did a good job, very cool, Paula, hot performance, sexy, Simon, preferred to the first two, more contemporary, was a good performance. Haley and Phil on the way.
Haley, “Turn the Beat Around”, solid start, her vocals were a little muddled from the backup singers, nice stage presence, and she’s clearly having a good time. Not a bad job from Haley. Judges: Randy, really karaoke, Paula, a fun song, you had fun up there, Simon, think she has a very good tactic, wear the least amount of clothes as possible. Vocals were rushed. Haley will be in the bottom three this week.
Phil, “Maria, Maria”, Phil using his smooth side on this one, he’s very comfortable on stage tonight, it’s nice to be able to hear Phil’s vocal range and his voice, he’s having some fun with it as well. Best of the night so far. Judges: Randy, didn’t quite connect, Paula, vocally it was good vocal, Simon, found the no originality in the performance, nothing to get positive or excited about. Up next, Jordin and Blake, which means Sanjaya is closing the show….interesting.
Jordin, “Rhythm is Gonna Get You”, like the look tonight, solid vocal, great stage presence and so far, the BEST of the night. She’s having fun, and the little run away from the lead vocal is great, she put her on touch on the song, WOW! Judges: Randy, that was hot, Paula, so authentic, your you, out there having a great time, Simon, feel about you they way I’ve felt all night, they’re all okay performances. Blake next…
Blake, “I Need to Know”, a asolid start, seems a little robotic, nice vocals with the run toward the end of the song. Best of the night so far, he could have been a little more risky. Judges: Randy, liked it, best song choice of the night, Paula, very smart performance, Simon, best choice of the night, best performance so far. Sanjaya up next….
Sanjaya, “Besame Mucho”, I mentioned in my blog about the possibility of someone doing a Spanish song, but I didn’t expect him to do it…well, he’s singing the song, a little Spanish, and some English too. He did a solid job. Judges: Randy, really good, Paula, good pitch, smooth, nice, very very nice, Simon, right, I couldn’t understand a word of it, it wasn’t horrible.
The wrapup of the evening coming in a few…

Idol Thoughts Top 8 Preview:Jennifer Lopez

Well, break out the bongo drums, it's Latin Week on Idol!
This Week Jennifer Lopez is the vocal coach for the remaining eight. Check out the latest podcast on the right, and then come back and let me know your Idolthoughts.
www.idolthoughts.us

Gina gets the Boot, Sanjaya is feeling "Fantastic"

Although I'm not. I'm glad that Gina, the one soul rocker this season made it this far. Sanjaya seems to have ruined Idol this year for several contestants, and that run seems to continue. Brandon and Stephanie are living in the Idol Oblivion of not having the chance to be on tour, which is very unfortunate since I feel they were both better than Mr. Hairstyle.
Next week, some latin flair on Idol with Jennifer Lopez, we'll have a preview Monday.

Tony Bennett, Boobs and Not a Hooters in Sight!

First off, kudos to Sanjaya for not going for the KFC bowl for the rest of his life. He actually sounded okay tonight, but I may have had something in my ears. Overall, the evening was solid from beginning to end. Lakisha is becoming a little 'old' to me. I know she has this big, booming voice, but part of me doesn't like her that much anymore.
Onto who did well, Blake started off the night well, Melinda knocked another one out of the park, and even Mr, Malakar showed off some personality and had a dance with Paula, which will most likely keep him safe again this week. Who's headed home...the bottom three...Haley, Phil, and Chris Richardson this week are at risk.
Don't forget the podcasts, I'll let you know who is going home this week and you may be surprised.

Standards with Tony Bennett: Top 9

Time to start another evening of Sanjaya's hair...if he has a 'bowl' style, KFC will give him free KFC Bowls for a year...(read that on Ken Tucker's site from USA Today). Solid piece on Tony Bennett...Blake up first....
Blake, "Mack the Knife", solid performance from Blake, nice to see two slow to medium tempo tunes in a row from him, he's gettin into it, like the dance moves, nice on the close...Judges: Randy, very good way to start, perfect song for him, Paula, personified pizzaz, a hipcat, just cool, Simon, good choice of song, give him 7/10, band 8/10. Nice start to the evening from Blake.
Phil and Melinda next....
Phil, "Night and Day", another slowdown, which is good. seemed a little sluggish at the start, liked what he did with singing the song title, showing off some range toward the end. Nice job. Judges: Randy, interesting choice, sang it good, didn't feel any passion, Paula, reminiscent of a young Frank Sinatra, have more joy, Simon, had all the joy of somebody singing in a funeral parlor, completely and utterly gloomy and slightly dark.
Melinda, "I've Got Rhythm", slow and sultry from Mel, very comfortable on the stage, she's on all her notes, like the band tonight with her too, and back to the slow for the close, she's brought it home tonight, outta the park for Melinda. Judges: Randy, gives everyone a lesson in singing, this is how you do it right here, Paula, like a master class, Simon, thought the second half was fun, doesn't think they'll ever be able to criticize her.
Chris Richardson and Jordin up next.
Chris, "Mr. Saturday Night", good stage presence, good start to the song, he's singing with some emotion tonight, good close. Judges: Randy, came out with a vengence, very cool and young and hip, Paula, made it hip and cool, Simon, made it hip and worked out out very well, one of the strongest tonight.
Jordin, "On a Clear Day", she's on pitch, nice beginning, she's singing from the heart, like she's giving advice to a friend who is down. She seems very comfortable on stage, great note on the close. Wow! Look out for Jordin...Judges: Randy, we got some heat up here, that was the bomb again, Paula, you are this magnet of joy and you exude it on stage, I'm just so freakin' proud, I don't know what to say, Simon, thinks she sang it very well, but was very traditional and old fashioned. Jordin is one to watch in this competition, I've said that before and I'm sure I'll say it again. Gina and Sanjaya up next. I mentioned in the podcast about the 'rockers' this week on the show, what will Gina do?
Gina, "Smile", I like what she did with her hair tonight, she was singing with some emotion, but didn't get into it till about 3/4 of the way through. Not a bad song for her. Judges: Randy, that was a very nice controlled performance, Paula, a flawless performance, sentimental, Simon, had two other females tonight with better vocals.
Sanjaya, "Heaven", well, it's Sanjaya, he's very smiley tonight, ooh and he dances with Paula, well he's the one who's had the most fun tonight so far, he managed to pull off a rather solid vocal too! Judges: Randy, can't even comment on the vocals, turned into a great entertainer, Paula, I get why people love you, your charming, Simon, uh, lets try a different tactic this week, incredible.
Haley coming up next, which means Lakisha closes the show again this season and has a chance to top Melinda this week.
Haley, "Savin' My Love for You", liked the off stage start, shows she's comfortable, she's having some fun with the performance and is hitting her notes, another great female vocal tonight! Judges: Randy, fits her vibe, Paula, did I tell you green is a good color?, Simon, I think you've got great legs, a good style of music. Not a bad performance from Haley, if it was earlier in the night, I think the judges would have been more enthusiastic. Lakisha to close the show next.
Lakisha, "Stormy Weather", nice sultry start for Lakisha, great vocals. Judges: Randy, love this, saved it all for the middle and the end, Paula, sound beautiful, Simon, that was a sassy great performance.
Back with the recap in a few, a good night overall for everyone!

Sanjaya Safe and a Sligh Goodbye

I don't know what it is with this guy. He's like one of those clown punching balloons, he just keeps coming back...again not in the bottom three. However Chris Sligh did deserve to be in the bottom three, and headed home tonight.
Gwen Stefani did an awesome performance of "The Sweet Escape", although I don't think Akon added much to the performance, aside from yelling at the crowd.
Next week should be great. A night of Classic Standards with Tony Bennett. Check out the podcast on Paula Abdul from last week if you haven't had the chance, you'll get a laugh from her 'Bedroom Choreography", and what she thinks of Simon's outfits.
A new podcast is up about the ramifications of Chris leaving, plus THE American Standard
next week!

Enjoy the rest of the week, and we'll have a podcast preview of Tony Bennett Monday...

Gwen Stefani Night: Lots of Colors, Stilettos and a Tragic Episode with a Dunk in Bathwater

Gwen Stefani night on Idol and a lot of great tunes tonight. The Police, The Cure, and some No Doubt for flavor. Sanjaya was in need of some Bathwater for his hair tonight, and Haley looked great in that black dress, but vocally didn't hit the mark. Lakisha is back, but Melinda is still at the top of her game. Blake was smooth with the Cure but Chris Sligh needed to take a breath before performing tonight. He didn't sound good at all, and missed his mark tonight. Bottom three this week. Haley, Chris Sligh, and Sanjaya. Who's headed home, check out the podcast early tomorrow.

Gwen Stefani Top 10(5-1)

Phil, "Every Breath You Take", not a bad rendition, again the echoes are driving me nuts. Solid vocal tonight, definitely no LeAnne Rimes this week, liked the close. Judges: Randy, solid performance, didn't push it, Paula, good choice, real good performance, Simon, thought that was very good, great choice of song. Melinda up next. Gwen said she would say good luck, but she didn't think Melinda needed it that much...What a compliment!
Melinda, "Heaven Knows", great start, the dress fits the song, solid vocal, amazing stage presence, knockout! Judges: Randy, sing with feeling, you are living the words, the bomb again, Paula, you have charisma from the word go, it's fun, and you do it, Simon, vocally outstanding, hate the outfit....thank you Simon...Blake and Jordin next, which means that Chris Richardson closes the show....
Blake, "Love Song", not bad, he's staying within the dynamic of the song. Good performance from him. Judges: Randy, wasn't jumping up and down but I liked it, Paula, taking risks, being original, Simon, strongest guy in the competitions. Jordin up next
Jordin, "Hey Baby", not a bad start, good stage presence, it appears to be boot night on Idol, took her about 3/4 of the song to show some vocal range with the song. Judges: Randy, was a very risky thing to do, that was brilliant. Paula, your adorable, Simon, most improved contestant the last few weeks, more confident...Chris Richardson to close the show with more No Doubt...
Chris Richardson, "Don't Speak", start was good, his vocal is okay, the band rendition was different, liked the R&B feel. Judges: Randy, liked it, Paula, Chris good, Simon, better choice of song, not crazy about the vocal, struggled in the middle.
Back with the recap of the night in a few....solid night of performances tonight....

Gwen Stefani: Top 10(10-6)

Gwen Stefani tonight, here we go..Lakisha up first with some Donna Summer, "Last Dance", well she has the voice, a good start for the night. I even like the dress, it matches the song. It seems like a safe week for Lakisha, a great vocal for a great song, but no notes that are blowing me away. She played it safe. Judges: Randy, did that like a diva, Paula, did Donna Summer proud, Simon, love the boots, now she's thirty years younger this week, nice to see her doing an uptempo song, great vocal. The "Rockers", Chris Sligh and Gina up next.
Chris Sligh with some Police, "Every Little Thing She Does", rough start for Chris, made it sound okay though, not sure I love the 'mic echo' on him. Seemed a tad karoke to me and his vocal was not on tonight. Judges: Randy, couldn't get into tempo, Paula, staying in the pocket becomes an eyesore, didn't feel the bit, Simon, I thought it was a mess, it was all over the place, didn't feel right. Hopefully for Chris there will be a WORSE performance tonight from another contestant. Gina up next.
Gina, "I'll Stand By You", good start for her, she looks great, nice job slowing it down this week, she's singing with some emotion tonight too, unlike last week when she was screaming with emotion. Nice close. Judges: Randy, one of her best performances ever, Paula, improving each week, great song choice, best performance so far, Simon, wasn't one of her best performances, was her BEST performance. It's all about knowing who you are, and the right song choice. Chalk and cheese....at any rate...up next, Sanjaya.
Sanjaya is nervous in front of Gwen, singing some "Bathwater", Sanjaya, hey man, the VO5 people will be thrilled, liked the hair! Vocal start was a little rough, he then started bobbing his head and the vocal got better(I think)...I don't get it. Judges: Randy, hairdo is interesting, you can sing you just need to put it out there, Paula, didn't do it, Simon, I presume there was no mirror in your dressing room tonight, doesn't matter what we say anymore, your in your own universe and if people like you, good luck. Haley up next.
Haley, "True Colors", good start, any girl looks good in a black dress, sounds much sweeter this week, she has incredible stage presence this week, more than last week. Nice little ride at the end vocally..Wow...Judges: Randy, was alright for him. Paula, one of those songs, requires nothing but singing the melody, didn't stay younger, Simon, it was sweet but forgettable, nothing to remember, too safe. Phil and Melinda next...

Gwen Stefani Tonight!

Gwen Stefani has been announced as the vocal coach for this evening, more in the podcast on my thoughts about tonight. 10 Performances tonight, and we'll be here to handicap along with the show, then Gwen performs The Sweet Escape tomorrow night with Akon before the results!
Back this evening with the rundown.

Idol Musings....Paula Abdul

A new post about Paula Abdul is up on the podcast site
http://idolthoughts.mypodcast.com

It includes my thoughts on her, plus her thoughts on Simon's wardrobe, her bedroom secret...when it comes to choreography(what were you thinking?), and why she is so damn nice. As well as some commentary on the guy who won't get voted off, regardless of anything it seems. Enjoy the weekend, back on Monday

Did British Invasions Include Sex Appeal, Zombies and the Hula Skirt?

Well, it was another reminiscing night on American Idol, classic British tunes done by the Top 11, some well, some okay enough to be considered "safe" this week, and a few people yelled their way through their songs, one the judges enjoyed, the other..uh...not so much, but Ashley, she liked them all tonight.
As for who is heading home, there are a few choices or many, depending on you point of view. One could be Haley, her performance was better, but has she endeared herself enough with voters to stick around? Sanjaya...now where have we heard that name before? dude, better, but there wasn't much singing and this isn't a talking competition, my third, as much as I like the Rocker image, is Gina. Tonight was not her best. Chris Richardson went slow tonight and did a great job, but he falls into the same category as Haley. Stephanie and Lakisha had a small blemish put on their winning chances tonight, but both could rebound, and no doubt will. Phil is in an interesting spot, with his background, being in the Armed Forces, how long will he be around? His tune didn't do much for me tonight. Bottom Three: Sanjaya, Gina, Phil...who's headed home? Sanjaya says Gina...Gina says Sanjaya and Phil says "Simon says" and he is safe.
Gina headed home...Your thoughts? Let me know...more on the podcast coming shortly....

Top 11(4-1) British Invasion Night

Jordin Sparks kicks off the final five tonight. "I Who Have Nothing", should be an interesting song, a very big song for her, let's see if she can pull it off..
Jordin...solid start to the song, she's putting a lot of emotion into the song, she's holding her own, with this one, WOW!..great job...Judges, Randy: very tall order, great performance, best of the night, Paula: wonderful performer, Simon: sang it beautifully, feel like jumping off a bridge, it was so gloomy, I want the sun to shine, sang it beautifully. That's two weeks in a row Jordin has had solid performances, her stock is headed up for sure. The WILD side of Sanjaya next? Please don't let it involve a Hula skirt....PLEASE....Sanjaya, "You Really Got Me"..."Something Good", which will he choose..."You Really Got Me", picked a big rock song, WAY too big for his voice, he's using the stage to his advantage, he sounds like he's shouting, rather than singing, you don't "Really Got MY Vote"...Judges, Randy: shocked me, came out of your shell, best performance to date, Paula: went for it, was a lot of fun, Simon: I think the little girl's face says it all.
It must be something in the soda cups tonight, yes Sanjaya showed a lot personality, and it may keep him in this for I hate to say it another week. Up next...Gina..."Paint it Black"...
Gina...sticking with her "rock" theme where she is the strongest..great start, on key, not sure who is having more fun, her or the drummer. solid stage presence. Judges, Randy: loved the edge, little pitcy, Paula: miles better than last week, what you have fun doing, Simon: moments of complete torture, off melody, vocally not good enough...Gina wasn't close with that song tonight, I hope she gets another chance...Chris Sligh next..."She's Not There"...this should show off his vocal range, he should do really well with this tune.
Chris Sligh, "She's Not There"...starting in the audience, nice...sounds greathe's hitting his notes, great stage presence, but Paula is sitting! Judges, Randy: wound up good, ended it strong, a little rough, Paula: dressing much nicer, be more personable, vocals were good, Simon: did your thing, thought it was fun, good choice of song, showed personality, better than last week. the audience navigation looked a little rough. Up next...to close the show, Melinda....
Melinda, "As Long as He Needs Me"...another slow song, she is kind of falling into the same thing Lakisha did. We know she'll still sound good in thirty years. She's hitting higher notes than Lakisha, and what is with the little girl in the audience tonight? Judges, Randy: saved the best for last, Paula: your in your own league, it's not forced, Simon: made the second part of the song sensational with an impeccable vocal. ..well, the weeks are getting better I think..recap in a few....

Top 11(11-5) British Invasion Night

Time to break out the British Sound on Idol...liked the Paula/Simon riff raff to start the show...Haley up first tonight. "Tell Him"...going to be aggressive...hmmm
Haley...good start, great stage presence. She seems a lot more comfortable on the stage. She's hitting her notes, like the little 'agressive' vocal change, great smile, and the dance moves were okay....Judges, Randy: perfect song for her, back in the competition, Paula: perfect song, flirtation was great, Simon: different side to you, it was fun, young, people are going to be talking about a lot more than her singing....I agree with Randy, her best so far. Second of the night, Chris Richardson, Mr. Justin Timberlake...."Don't Let the Sun Catch You Cryin'"..
Chris...with just a guitar...nice start...nice job slowing it down this week. Is on his notes, sounds good. He' s hitting his higher notes tonight. It's good to hear Chris do a slower song, rather than the last few weeks where he was kinda everywhere. Good song choice....Judges, Randy: showed a different side to him, every note was in tune, Paula: all about being smart, arrangement very sexy and charming, Simon: I think that was your best performance ever, excellent control, did his own slant...Stephanie next. "You Don't Have to Say You Love Me"...looking for her to knock this one out of the studio tonight!
Stephanie...liked the little horn section intro...little rough on the start, but she worked it out beginning of the second verse. It was alright for me, she had a few problems, lets see what the judges said. Randy: not best performance, pitchy, hard when people sing a lot of uptempo songs. Paula: loved what she is wearing, picked the right song. Simon: thinks she is losing her edge and her soul, bit nightclubby, not necessarily her, is becoming far to old for herself..Simon hit in the head, the song was too old for her, but I loved the dress...Blake up next..."Time of the Season"
Blake: well, he's putting his own spin on it...good start, they're up and dancing. Nice vocals so far, he has some major stage presence and confidence with this song tonight. Vocal is great. Ooh, like the beatboxing, originality..what will the judges say on that one...like the arrangement from the band...nice job. Blake's best performance...Judges, Randy: edgy massive yo factor of a song, made it current, much props, Paula: really raised the bar, at a concert, Simon: million times better than last week, think this week chose the right song without messing with the melody, strongest performance so far....I again, agree with Simon, strongest of the night so far, it was fun, entertaining and he was having fun with it.
Lakisha next..."Your My World", a first this season, a song switch for Lakisha, "Diamonds Are Forever"..good stage presence and she is channelling "Ursula" from the Little Mermaid at several points of her performance, not a Disney performance, but she stayed within the constraints of the song...the song seemed to go on forever and I feel she is at risk....Judges, Randy: not his favorite, didn't feel enough Lakisha in it, Paula: think she made the right choice, wearing a million dollars worth of diamonds, Simon: this was Lakisha in fifty years time, wasn't his favorite performance..Phil next, "Tobacco Road"
Phil..little rock edge...nice start, audience is up...solid stage presence, vocal was solid, liked the little riffs toward the end, good ending. Judges, Randy: it was pretty good for me, Paula: good choice of song, some pitchy parts, liked the vocal range he showed, Simon: wasn't crazy about it. Kind of a third division bar band performance, didn't hear any grit in his voice.
Putting the wrap on the first half, Simon said Phil is being outsung tonight, and I have to agree. Blake, Haley, and Chris did the best out of this group and showed off their range and their skill the best. Lakisha wasn't as amazing as she has been in previous weeks, but gets the Disney vote from me. Stephanie had the opportunity to lay down the law tonight and she didn't take the chance, and Phil I didn't get...good thing for Steph, there is another singer's name that starts with an S that has yet to sing...

Invasion from the Other Side of the Pond

Getting set for the evening on Idol. Should be an entertaining night. Another one of performances and songs that we haven't heard in a while. I'm looking forward to see if anyone 'changes' any songs to fit their style. Sixties and British Invasion, I wasn't born yet, but I'm Smarter than a Fifth Grader and know that in the Sixties we weren't invaded....musically yes, literally no....back in a few to start the night and your Top 11.

Past Idols on Regis and Kelly

Some of your favorite Idol's will be performing on Regis and Kelly This Week:

Monday was Brandon Rogers, he did Time After Time, and sounded okay. He said he knew he was going to be voted off after that performance because he didn't endear himself or his performance to America.
Tuesday: Elliott Yamin(will post details after each performance)
Wednesday: Bucky Covington
Thursday: Josh Gracin
Friday: Sanjaya(the person voted off this week....may be wishful thinking)

British Invasion Week Preview

Hope everyone had a great weekend. All signs point to British Invasion week this week on Idol. Beatles, Monkees and the like. My question is will anyone do a new "spin" on one of these classic tunes and will they be slaughered by the judges for it. It would not surprise me if one did, and they got praise from all three judges. After last week and Blake's performance, which I thought was great..Sligh's wasn't bad either, but they both got hand downs from the judges. You can read more on my rant of originality and hear it in last week's blog and podcast from after the show.
This week I'm not sure what to expect. The guys have a great chance to step it up this week, if they choose the right tunes. A few of the women may have problems this week. I'm looking for Haley and possibly Jordin to stuble a little.
In the podcast today(the link is on the right)...Simon on 60 Minutes, the "Howard Stern Effect", and a new Sanjaya term...
Let me know what you think...I'll be back with a blow by blow blog of the show on Tuesday

New Podcast.."Idol Looks" Now Available...

What is the "Idol Look" and who has used it to their advantage. In the six seasons of Idol, two come to mind. That, and a strange reference to the King of Pop. Check out the podcast site listed on the right. You can also click to http://idolthoughts.mypodcast.com

Aaaah, Make Way for the Incredible, Reappearing....oh never mind...

Once again, as it seems to be this year on Idol, what the rest of America hears and what my ears are hearing seems to be off. I'm not sure what it is, oh wait...I got it...over twenty eight million votes last night and seven to eight million of them voted for Sanjaya because he's "cute" and deserves another opportunity to be meager and ordinary on a show that at this point is totally and completely NOT about being meager and ordinary. Not to mention the eight million of them that voted are most likely giddy thirteen year old girls, which no one can compete against.
Another person with promise was taken down last night, although he was falling off in recent weeks, but he should have known he needed to do better and NOT forget the words. Brandon was axed last night, but I don't think he's too worried. He had the opportunity to show off his talent on the national stage and gain some exposure. He already has a deal with a record company, as a backup singer. It's just a matter of time for him.
Ok, enough on that...there was plenty of promise to go around this week. The person that helped herself the most this week was Jordin, and last night she looked great with straight hair. Haley was a close second, she had some great poise on the big stage the other night.
In the podcast for the upcoming weekend, "Idol Looks", what the show does to and for people's image. A look into past "Idol Looks" successes, and an unexpected Michael Jackson reference. I've also moved "Idol Musings" up for those who haven't heard it. The topic is potential Theme Weeks on this season's Idol. Some good, some not so good.
Check out the podcasts on the top right and have a great weekend!

Female Vocalists, Male Singers and "The VO5 Vote"

Well, if last night is any indication a cat fight may break out between the Ladies this season in order for a winner to be named. With their performances many showed that they did belong. There were a few that I did not understand as far as song choice, and more on that in the podcast. Some even played it 'safe' last night, and with a new stage and bigger audience the nerves did show.
I feel bad for Blake, he used his own insight and creativity in remaking a great song, the vocal was alright, however the judges totally lambasted his version of the song. Isn't Idol about making the point to be original and standout. I've heard that phrase from day one, and Blake now stands out, if we could only make the boy sing a song that was familiar to more than 5% of the Nation that would be great. A solid start to that this week for him.
Haley and Jordin really added to their popularity and stepped up their game last night. Great poise on both of their parts. For those that forgot their words, there is NO excuse. This is Season 6 and you have to to better than that, it is expected of you.
Who's headed home? I think that Sanjaya isn't getting enough attention, and I fear that if he sticks around another week, he may shave his head or go into rehab. He was the poorest performance of the night, but may get enough votes from his hair that he will survive till next week. Chris Richardson was upbeat, but I fear he may be at risk of heading home. Perhaps it will be Stephanie? It is early enough in the season for a few 'Shock Lack of Voting' Exits...Phil, Stephanie, and Brandon may also be on the chopping block.
More in the podcast, the link is off to the right.

Idol Thoughts Top 12(6-1) Week 1: Diana Ross Tribute Week

Phil Stacey is next...he, like Haley should be looking for a solid performance this week, yes it's Diana Ross, but it's gotta be better than LeAnne Rimes. (for his sake, I hope so)
Phil, "I'm Gonna Make You Love Me", much better pitch this week from last week, good stage movement, the band is keeping it down, I'm really hearing some nice vocals from Phil tonight, like the sax touch. He's comfortable and seems to be having fun. Judges: Randy, gets voice award for the night. Paula, vocals were good, needs to be more uptempo. Simon, chose the right tempo, it was okay, good song choice. It wasn't outstanding, wasn't awful.
It's good to hear some of these songs redone, it's been a while, even though when most of them were done before I was born, I still know the music. Lakisha next.
Lakisha, "God Bless the Child", her vocal is always going to be great, and is again tonight, she has some great stage presence, make the record, I'll buy it tomorrow. Judges: Randy, perfect song choice, unbelievable vocal, sensational. Paula, beautiful performer, heart comes through when you sing. Simon, you've either got it or you haven't got it, and you've got it. the quality difference between you and Melinda...you two are in a different league...I agree with Simon, it was a great performance..coming up..Blake Lewis..I've been looking forward to see what Blake was going to do for the last week.
Blake, "Keep Me Hangin' On", I like the risk he's taking with changing the song...I'm impressed...very comfortable on stage. I like the mix, good vocals tonight. Best male performance and best energy too...crowd is up and Paula is rockin' out. I liked the acapella touch...WOW! Judges: Randy, let the classics be the classics. Paula, a real good singer Simon, didn't get it at all. the three judges tonight say Don't mess with the classics. I disagree, I thought it was totally original, and the vocal was decent. The whole point of this show is to be original and standout from everyone else, and Blake did that tonight...Stephanie next..
Stephanie, "Love Hangover", solid performance from Steph, good vocal, good stage presence, nice note at the end. Good energy tonight. Judges: Randy, good vocal, strong finish, perfect choice for her. Paula, strong vocals, strive for better. Simon, strange arrangement of the song, sang the intro, didn't close well. Chose the wrong song. I thought she did a decent job, she should be okay for next week. Chris Richardson next...
Chris Richardson, "The Boss", okay on the intro, seems a tad nervous, good tempo tune for him, aah the first to work the runway behind the judges this year. He's got the audience involved, solid performance from him. Judges: Randy, overdid it a little bit, was half and half. Paula, out of all the guys, brought contemporary the best. Simon, thought the vocals were dreadful if you took out his charm and personality...I wasn't familiar with the song, I thought he was pretty solid...Jordin closes the show...
Jordin, "If We Hold on Together", she has some poise on the stage tonight, more so than some of the guys, she's holding her own and sounds pretty solid. She seemed a bit pitchy, like she is yelling into the mic. She's having some fun out there. Nice close to the show. Wow. Judges: Randy, so impressed with you, tonight just made it a three girl race. Paula, a breath of fresh air, drew me in right away with the song. Simon, a bit gooey, very very good vocal, absolutely put herself in with a shot of the finals.
Overall a good night with Diana Ross tunes. Back with a recap in a bit...Jordin stepped it up big time and do I need to say anything about Sanjaya?...

Idol Thoughts Top 12(12-7) Week 1:Diana Ross Tribute Week

Alright, the “Fro Patrol” sign was clever…Sanjaya’s look tonight…a Perm? Perhaps he’ll have a Michael Jackson “Pepsi” accident and be bald next week. Nice piece on Diana Ross and off we go with Brandon.
Brandon, “Can’t Hurry Love”, great stage presence..like the look, fits the song. He seems like his tempo is off from the band. OUCH…forgot the words, or missed from the tempo..well looks like Sanjaya’s safe and he hasn’t even performed yet..BIG stage, something to get used to…Judges: Randy, forgot the words Paula: nerves, many things he does right Simon: complete letdown, very predictable version, dancing was terrible. No star quality, no originality…I feel I have to agree with Simon…Melinda next. But before, gotta love the Idol banter…
Melinda, “Home”, nice entrance, good stage presence, her notes are on, very soulful performance, great performance, we’ll see but that’s gonna be tough to beat. Judges: Randy, still really strong, was hot. Paula, feeling so much joy, so excited, this is it(need I mention Paula is falling apart. Simon, remind me of a young Gladys Knight, very good. Melinda seems shell shocked that she actually hit the notes that she hit and she sounded great. Again, gonna be tough to beat.
Chris Sligh, “Endless Love”, liked Diana’s thought about finding the melody. We’ll see..seems a tad nervous on the “big stage”..the arrangement of the song is interesting, managed to pull it through in the end I thought. Tough song for his ‘Rock’ voice. Seemed a little “show tuney”. Judges: Randy, not worry about the sound, was a mess. Paula, worry less about trying to fit into something contemporary. Simon, took song and turned it into a drone. Unemotional, uninspiring, keep the glasses…Gina next…
Gina, “Love Child”, good stage intro, on key, solid stage presence, liked how the band gave her some good mic time by bringing it down a little. Song fits her voice well. She did a solid job. Judges: Randy, it was pitchy, didn’t feel any excitement. Paula, feel good, much better than how she did tonight. Simon, wasn’t terrible or fantastic. Chose the right song for her, is a little forgettable….Gina did the right song for her voice, but seemed to play it safe, a good idea to get used to the crowd, but she shouldn’t do it too often. Sanjaya up next.
Sanjaya, “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough”, well, seems like he’s grown up a little, but is struggling with the stage a little. Vocally he’s okay, nowhere NEAR Melinda..Judges: Randy, wasn’t very good. The hair is rockin, Hair idol he’d be great. Paula: you smile and it warms people’s hearts. Simon: when you hear a wail in Beverly Hills, that is where Diana Ross is watching this show. Very brave…it’s tough for Sanjaya, the guy is seventeen and I don’t think has come into his voice yet...Haley next…
I hope that Haley rebounds from the poor performance from last week. She is lucky to have a place in the Top 12 and I think she knows it.
Haley, “Missing You”, great song for her..could potentially be the best of the night. It’s an okay start for her, ouch, flubbed the words, not good. It’s funny what the big stage does to performers, the long note was nice. I’m disappointed with her tonight, she knows she could have done better. Judges: Randy, gave it a valued effort, sounded nervous, was pitcy. Paula, look lovely tonight, still adorable. Simon, didn’t think it was that bad, think she had real presence, looked like a star, nerves got the best of her. Thanks Simon for making Haley’s night. He’s spot on though, her best is yet to come, minus the nerves.
Six down, six to go Phil is next…back in a sec…

Gettin' Set for Diana

Another night of Idol is upon us..looking for the ladies to shine tonight..some of the guys may have some trouble..looking forward to hear what the 'coach' has to say to Sanjaya...back shortly with the first six performances.

Idol Thoughts: For Your Review, Top 12Week 1: Diana Ross

Diana Ross, a name synonymous with hit songs. The Idol coach this week, and some struggles ahead for some of the contestants. Who may have issues this week? Check out the podcast page on the right.
http://www.idolthoughts.us

First SHOCK and HUH? of the Season

Well, last night it happened. I am as shocked as the judges were. Sundance, Sabrina, Jared, and Antonella are gone - only the latter was expected in my mind. The Top 12 has some people that were given a shot across their port bow last night...step it up or step into mediocrity quickly. The opportunity these guys and gals have from this moment on is huge. No more nerves, or struggles to hit notes, or poor song choices.
This upcoming week should prove to be very entertaining with Diana Ross being the vocal coach and honorary "Theme Week" choice.
Of course this competition is supposed to be who has the best "talent" as far as singing goes, however over the past few years it has become much more than that, as far as knocking the wrong people off the show. America, get it together!
I am amazed that Sunjaya has gotten as far as he has being a mediocre talent, aside from his first auditions for the show he has been a fish out of water and better get comfortable quick.
What are your thoughts on what went down last night? Is it fair to give Haley, Phil, and Sunjaya spots in the Top 12?

Top 8 Women Recap Channeling and "Changing the Collection to CDs"

Well, it wasn't a complete blow away. but it was far better than Tuesday night. A nice start to the night with Jordin doing Pat Benatar, possibly one of the stronger performances of the night, far better than what she did the past few weeks. Perhaps Antonella should stick with the violin after that performance, it was better than previous weeks, but will her "prettiness" keep her around for another week, that seems to be about 90% what she has going for her.
I felt bad for Haley, knowing she had the heavy hitters behind her she needed to come close to hitting one out of the park, and didn't. Lakisha did not disappoint, as usual. Stephanie showed off why she belonged....Gina, girl maybe you should have tackled that song drunk, because sober, it didn't work. Melinda closed out the show with some Peggy Lee.
The women are far better at choosing songs this week. For the most part they are picking songs to showcase their talent. They need to teach this 'technique' to the guys. Who goes home...Antonella, Gina, and Haley are the bottom three. Antonella and Haley are at the bottom in my eyes and ears this week.

Top 8 Guys ReviewIn the Words of Howie, "Ladies, Please...SAVE Us!"

Not very impressive this evening, rather luke warm. I have seen some people who do karaoke in this town do better performances than some of the ones from last night. Some were totally off key, Phil, some sounded possesed, Phil, and others were just okay, everyone else. Some of these guy appear to be song choice blind, which is better than tone deaf...oh, wait...we had some of that last night too..
the podcast isn't much more positive, but I do have who is headed home, which could be any of six of these fellas. ..Ladies tonight...one or two high notes hit for me and it'll be considered a runaway. The guys were THAT dreadful this week...

Top 8 Guys Review

Well, the final cuts are just about here to get to the Top 12. Sanjaya is apparently going for the drowned rat look this evening…oooh, a revealing event on Thursday??? Hmmm…should be a fun podcast in the morning….wow, straight to it….Blake up first…
Blake: liked the beat boxing, “311”, interesting processing on the mic…not quite sure what to think of this one…I’ll give him an A for originality…Judges: Randy, loved the hip hop reggae thing, Paula, was interested, even though she didn’t know the song. Simon: didn’t understand a word, agreed with Randy and Paula, making it current. A nice start to the evening, with a twist if you please…
Sanjaya, the Hula King, or should I say…Boy Prince..up next, “John Mayer”, feedback on the mic tonight…is he singing, or talking his way through this one…stage presence is pretty weak, somewhat karaoke, had some issues on the high note…Judges: Randy, no energy to start, hasn’t returned to form, not that great, Paula: try to get out of his comfort zone, keep tryin. Simon: wasn’t as bad as last week, Paula hairstyle going over the top, wasn’t a good vocal. Again, Sanjaya, “Waiting for some votes to change”…
Sundance, “Pearl Jam”, fits his voice completely, stage presence is okay, took him part of the performance to get into it, but great note at the end, he picked the right song. Judges: Randy: put the Southern rock thing on, Paula: kicked in his groove, Simon: didn’t like it as much as last week, lost his charm, “A generic bar singer”…
Chris Richardson, I’m actually looking forward to see what he does this week. “Cry” did a great job with that song, great stage presence, breaking out Keith Urban. Judges: Randy: in it to win it Paula: adapted well, Simon: it was good, not the best vocal, he sold it. Nice job slowing it down this week, did that one for his Grandma…Jared up next..
Jared needs to do well this week I think, or he may be headed home…doing some Stevie…pretty good stage presence, not a bad job in the middle, great play to the camera. Judges: Randy: gave a solid performance, was good Paula: needs to work on coloring the way he sings…apparently he needs some new Crayolas…Simon: wasn’t very original, gets lost in the mix, slightly disappointed. Not hearing the “Wow” factor…we’re five down, four to go..no WOW factor yet. I’m getting concerned for the guys.
Brandon, “Celebrate”…a rather eclectic selection of tunes tonight…great stage presence, he’s working well with the backup singers, it was decent for me. Judges: Randy: good choice, more of a rock edge, Paula: phenomenal, really getting in there and proving he belongs Simon: didn’t represent himself well, thinks that song may give him a problem this week..I’m going to agree with Simon.
Phil up next…”LeAnne Rimes”, not sure about the start, sounded like he was possessed, managed to pull through, very pitchy, not an easy song to sing. Not sure about that one. Judges: Randy: big range, work on the lows Paula: choice of song, not his best Simon: didn’t get it at all, insane at the beginning. Phil may be gone tonight.
Chris Sligh gets the final performance of the night…nice start, picked the right song, “We All Wanna Be Loved”, great stage presence…best performance of the night…Judges: Randy: gets the vocal prize Paula: wasn’t her favorite performance, was middle of the road, needs to stretch a little more Simon: beginning was good, then shouted in the middle, has potential…time to vote…the night overall for me, was alright, the big problem was there wasn’t a WOW performance from the guys and at this stage there needed to be. Tomorrow night will be a 180 from tonight, and the girls will put the guys away….recap from tonight in a bit…

Top 8 Guys Preview... Jitters, Adjectives, and NO Ballads Please...

Well, we're into Week 3 of Idol, the jitters and butterflies and technical issues should all be things of the past. The dogpound is ready to shout, Paula is ready for another exciting week of one word adjectives of praise and Simon, well..he's Simon.
Basically by now everyone has been through this enough to know what is expected. From the gentlemen tonight I am looking for two or three great performances, and at least one amazing, blow out the speakers, raise the roof performance...but who is it going to come from? Chris S or Sanjaya? Song choice is key. Who is going to go down in flames by doing a ballad tonight? Who is going to bring Simon to his feet?...sorry, Paula..wait, she's always on her feet.
Week 3 commences soon, don't forget about the podcast at the right and to let me know your thoughts here as well. Be back tonight with the usual blow by blow account...have a good Monday...

Fadoras, Green Dresses and Voting, Oh My!

Well, the American Public has surprised me again, letting AJ, Nick, Antonella, and Leslie. I think the fact that there are pretty people to swoon over this year is having an impact...but thats the case every year.
For anyone who has missed or would like a recap this year, I have posted some new podcasts titled...For Your Review, it's a recap of the Top 8 Guys and Gals, what they have done, and an early look at the Top 4, in my mind.
Also check out 'Idol Musings', for a look at my potential "Theme Weeks" this year. Enjoy the Weekend!

Stephanie, Melinda, and a Hideous Green Dress

Well, who knew that tonight on Idol would be, for the part ordinary and part fashion disaster. It would be nice to see the guys from Queer Eye on the show to help some of these girls with their fashion choices for the show. I don't think Gina or Antonella got it right for their songs, in particular the latter. A throwback to the days of A Christmas Story, it was a "green nightmare". If she was trying to get votes strictly by attire she would be voted off this week, but I think her voice was bad enough that its going to happen anyway.
Stephanie and Melinda stepped it up with their performances last night to land the one and two spots in front of Lakisha. Headed home for the girls, I already mentioned one. The other is either going to be Jordan or Whitney. It would not be a shock to me if Lakisha was on her way out...I've seen it happen before. More on "Dedication Week" in the podcast
Overall the week as better for the guys this week, and some of the girls fell off their game, while others stepped it up, but with it being Dedication Week, that was bound to happen.

Top Ten Women (10-1)

Right to it tonight…Gina up first
Gina: “Alone”…she did a nice job, great stage presence once she got going…great start to the night….didn’t help that the background singer was off pitch…great song choice for her. Judges: Randy: Liked it Paula: excellent job, really good Simon: good choice of song, felt vocals sounded forced. She did a great job, good way to start the show. She had fun on stage too…
Alaina up next…”Not Ready to Make Nice”…good stage presence…good tone, played to the camera well. Judges: Randy: tuning and pitch went away, not good. Paula: hard song to sing, pitch was off. Simon: like Randy taking part in 100 meter Sprint, ¾ way through the race he would run out of steam and that’s what happened to her. She looks great, not sure the ‘look’ will save her. I think she’ll be safe for next week.
Lakisha up next…and She’s NOT ready to make nice….”Midnight Train”..the song is great, but it seems a little too like the original for me, she’s hitting all her notes, but she’s playing it very safe tonight. I’m disappointed. Judges: Randy: that was hot. Paula: loved it. Simon: interesting dance at the end, didn’t think it was as good as last week. She can afford to believe and start acting like a big star. Didn’t like the outfit…Fashionsense with Simon Cowell will premiere on the E! Network Sunday at 9…next up, Melinda….
Slowing it down with “Funny Valentine”…great on the low notes, very Patty LaBelle like tonight, I believe we have a new front runner, at least for the night. Kudos to the band as well, great arrangement. Judges: Randy: unbelievable, is the one to beat. Paula: loved the phrasing, applauds her Simon: THAT was incredible. The best vocal this year. A breath of fresh air…I agree with Simon, Melinda came to win, amazing performance.
Antonella with Celine(yawn)…after the break.
Pitchy, flat, and headed home…”Because You Loved Me”…not a good song for her, painful to listen to…can’t wait for the fashion advice from Simon…ooh, that high note was painful…and so was her dress…Judges: Randy: completely wrong song, pitch all over the place. Paula: made leaps and bounds from last week. Simon: Vocals not good enough, thought she was worse than last week. Aaah, she pulled a Jennifer Hudson mention…the audience didn’t vote for Jennifer Hudson, and she can exit stage left with the green dress and may tomorrow night. Well, the good news is…Lakisha is safe...for now. 5 down, 5 to go…Antonella is the weakest so far, followed by Alaina, then Gina, Lakisha and Melinda at the top this week. I haven’t heard anything totally WOW caliper yet tonight from the women….
Jordan Sparks is in the six spot…
…great poise on stage…a little pitchy, she got caught up in the piece before the performance. ”Reflection”…did a good job on that song, liked the ease on the end…wow…Judges: Randy: great talent. Paula: brilliant girl Simon: wasn’t her best, excellent compared to others. Dedications got to her tonight, she’s only seventeen, very good. Dedications are getting to the girls a little more than the guys, but I hope it didn’t cost her, she should be back…apparently Jordan can’t count to add to the emotion…all she has to do is sing well…and she sang well enough…
Stephanie up next…”Dangerous Love”…tough song to sing, but she’s doing a solid job, great stage presence, lots of vocal changes and she made 99% of them flawlessly….Judges: Randy: proved she should be up there…little Beyonce like…Paula: fantastic, brilliant Simon: agree with Paula, not just taking part, coming out putting her mark down, thought it was terrific. I love the fact that Paula has entered her ‘adjective only’ part of the evening and she has taken Simon with her. Stephanie just did one of the best performances I’ve seen so far this year. Her and Melinda have done the right songs and have had the best performances so far.
Leslie up next…she’s promising a Flapless performance…she started out pretty good, band kept it low…not sure about the whole not singing words thing…Judges: Randy: little pitchy, liked the acapella. Paula: back in her element. Simon: been whacked by three or four voices before her, was better than last week. Leslie did a good job tonight, returning to the jazzy style, she was more comfortable on stage. Haley up next.
“Queen of the Night”..rollin’ with some Whitney…she’s having fun on stage…not so sure the song fits her, but she’s doing a solid job, it was okay for me..Judges: Randy: wasn’t great, vocally not on point. Paula: better than last week, get to see her personality. Simon: A for effort, little manic, verging on insane at one point. She is one of two or three very vulnerable girls tonight. Haley didn’t do anything with that performance to separate herself from the three (Melinda, Stephanie, Lakisha) ahead of her to stand out. I hope she is around for another week.
Wrapping the show tonight, Sabrina…with some Whitney…little pitchy…she figured it out though, sounds like she’s trying to force it a little, seems very pitchy to me…Judges: Randy: very nice Paula: big contender, bravo Simon: very good, don’t confuse power with shouting. It was okay for me. It’s tough to do a Whitney song without being compared to Whitney.
The night overall was solid, some women came down a little from last weeks performances, others really made it a point to stand out..more in the recap in a bit…

Top Ten Women...and Ants!

We're killing ants at Idol Central tonight...getting set for the Ladies tonight...look for Lakisha to shine an everyone else to take it personal. We should definitely have a clearer picture of the competition after tonight...it's another evening of Dedications....on the way...

Afternoon Things to Ponder...

I'm sitting here on a quiet afternoon...it's cold here in Oregon today, very brisk. As far as the men performing last night, you already know I wasn't that impressed. Among the people I talked with throughout the day today, they basically relected my thoughts. It's been an interesting year thus far. It's, of course, got a little scandal too with some photos surfacing on the internet, which I don't believe. The evening is almost set, just a few more hours and the Ladies will be on stage. It's going to be harder to say goodbye to this group of girls, two this week, than the guys. It would have been great if instead of knocking off two guys and two gals, they just knocked out four guys last week...thoughts on that in a new format for next year?
I have also added a search option for last season, in case anyone wants to take a look back. There is one for this season too, listed off to the right, below the podcast page. Catch you in a few hours.

Guys Night, Slightly Lackluster(Review)

I was hoping the guys would really step things up last night, since this week they were taking it "personal", however with Dedication Week, what happened for some, fell totally flat for others. Phil, Blake, Chris and Sundance proved they belonged in the competition, and Sanjaya proved he was too young to be involved in the competition....by trying to go older and more sophisticated I don't think he got the job done. He may be out tomorrow night.
There is a fine line for doing a song as a Dedication and doing a song showing you belonged in the competition. I am speaking of Brandon, and I did like his heartfelt version of "Time After Time", but it lacked more than what I gained from it. I hope he gets the votes and comes back to show off his voice more..we are still at the point of getting to know these contestants, but two guys have to head home this week.
A complete breakdown of the evening is in my latest podcast, the link is to the right. Be sure to come back and let me know your thoughts....ladies tonight, see you then

Top Ten Guys(10-1)

Here we go...love the Ryan intro..."The guys are back, and this time it's personal"....uh, hello...everything is personal if your a person...very classy note starting the show with a congrats to Jennifer Hudson..will he question Simon?? They are dedicating their performances this week to people that inspire them...he was last on Tuesday's show a week ago, and he is first tonight...
Phil gets it started..."Missing You"...solid start...good presence on the stage..not a great song as far as his range, but an okay start to the night...Judges: Randy: showing his power Paula: liked the tone, can hear him on the radio now...Simon: thinks he's popular, is a very nice guy with an unoriginal voice. Still not hearing anything unique...Well, best two out of three??? Simon doesn't see him leaving....
Jared..with some Marvin Gaye...hmmm...well, his tone is like Marvin's..and he sounds weak, like the dance moves...he's having a good time...pitchy...some of them..yikes...he took a chance...judges: Randy: steamy face move, liked it..Paula: good looking guy, kinda song he didn't have to push....(no pun intended)...Simon: glad he made the attempt, reminded him of the Love Boat, if they had a cabaret singer on the loveboat....comeback: that would have been a great loveboat, man....well apparently we're no longer a family show after some Marvin Gaye...hey, Jared had fun...AJ up next....
AJ taking a risk, very vulnerable with the band playing low..nice..."Feelin Good" good timing, he's got good timing, solid tone....Judges: Randy: better than last week, kinda nice Paula: has a real real real real real good voice. Simon: made himself standout, looked strangely comfortable...so far the best of the night for me...great arrangement too, liked the cold start, was different and unique...Sanjaya, next...
Sanjaya...like the look, fits the song...just not sure if the song 'fits' him...seems like another week where he didn't know song selection...seems very nervous, not projecting with his voice...Judges: Randy: nice kid, like a bad high school talent show, like he borrowed his dad's hat...Paula: sang on pitch, has an old soul, pick songs that celebrate your youth, Simon: agreed with Randy, weak, weird, no impact. Sanjaya seemed like he was whispering during the song, not sure what's in his head, but he may have a ticket punched for a trip home...and he'll be "Steppin Out" this week....
Chris, "Trouble" next...opposite of Sanjaya, picked the right song for his voice...sounds great, good stage presence, solid vocal tone...Judges: Randy: good to see him return, good choice Paula: liked it too, real awesome Simon: very good singer. One of the better ones tonight, although we're only through four..six to go, and I have a feeling the best of the night is still to come.
Nick and "Fever" next...little change of tempo from Richard Marx and "Now and Forever" last week...he's been here before, but didn't get this far remember...solid vocal from Nick, however the drummer seems to be more into the song than the singer...there are several ways he could have gone after this song, and he took the safe version, he didn't really make it his own, it was ordinary. Judges: Randy: nice Paula: liked it Simon: Thought it was good, lacked charisma on the song. again, lack of charisma this week, Blake Lewis next...
Blake..."Virtual Insanity"...did a great job at the start, with some vocal mixing...tome is great, stage presence is great, pretty good arrangement. Judges: Randy: good to see him return..liked it..Paula: smart choices, unique, no one else like him Simon: thought first part was copycat, didn't see any originalty, very disappointed....I disagree, I thought the performance was fine, the scatting in the middle was a nice touch.
Brandon Rogers up next.. Brandon singing "Time After Time"....his vocal is solid. Not a bad song, it's interesting hearing a male vocal on the song, not sure though...Judges Randy: liked the sentiment, didn't do a lot vocally. Paula: felt his heart in the song Simon: its a singing competition, needs to come out and make a 'wow' impact. needs to show why he's a great singer...Simon wants to hear it now...his performance was weak, even though he put his 'heart' into the performance..not too sure about that performance.
Chris Richardson, "Geek in Pink"..did Gavin DeGraw last week and it wasn't original...lets hope this isn't a slaughter. I like the stretch he is taking and the risk...solid vocal, good stage presence...judges: Randy: Chris is in it to win it tonight, lovin him tonight Paula: liked it Simon: best tonight by a mile...and I totally agree with Simon, he had a great time on stage, vocally he was on, best so far tonight...ONE to go...ONE...Sundance closes the show...
Sundance singing, "Mustang Sally"...great song for his voice...good way to end the show..solid performance, opening that big voice...even like the dance moves...Lakisha officially has some competition from the guys...best of the night...hands down....Judges: Randy: that was hot. Paula: bring it like that every week. amazing range. Simon: still thinks Sundance can do better, but a big improvement.
Tonight, overall better for the guys, with "Dedications" week you really can't do much or pick too much on these guys for the songs they chose to dedicate, or maybe you can...what do you think? I'll be back with a recap of the night for the guys shortly, ladies tomorrow....they're not sweating..that I know...back in a bit

Top Ten Guys....Step it Up?

Another Tuesday night....the Top Ten Guys...ended up watching the first third of Final Destination Three over the weekend, and still need to finish it.....or not...getting set for the guys Top 10...lets hope at least five of them step it up, if not all of them....back in a few..

Top 10 Men's Preview and Jennifer Hudson...

Well, the Oscars were as boring as they usually are last night. Ellen DeGeneres had some great moments, off stage and in the audience. Congrats to Jennifer Hudson on her Best Supporting Actress Oscar..I'm sure Simon is eating some crow for that one...more on that in Today's Podcast...as well as a breakdown of the Top Ten Men performing tomorrow night.

Idol Musings...Theme Nights....Potentials??

There is a new podcast posted about potential "Theme Nights" on Idol. Check it out at the podcast link on the right, and tell your "Idol Thoughts" here...
Enjoy the weekend....

Gettin the Boot..(24-20)//Part 2

Round two of tonights cuts...Nicole is gone, the girl from Philly performed okay last night I thought. the girl with a very unique voice on "Stay Together", is gone...last cut tonight, a guy....is it Sundance? PLEASE not Sundance.......well, the "Free Ride" for Rudy is over...he's the fourth cut tonight...no real surprises with who has departed this evening, then again when you have twenty three so so performances and one that knocks it out of the park, the vote can go any which way. Ken's blog on USA Today made a very valid point that when you vote, you are doing so for your 'favorite' contestant..not necessarily the best singer, and there were worse singers than some of those that left the show tonight...more on that in the podcast...have a good night, till next week on the blog...don't forget you can catch the podcast...the first link on the right-->.
Have a great weekend...See ya, Bye!

Gettin the Boot..(24-20)//Part 1

Well, here we go...the first to say goodbye...Paul...sorry he won't be able to sing anymore barefoot ballads, he had a lot of potential too and was a victim of poor song choice in my mind...this of course means that Sundance is fifty percent safe...on the girls side we say goodbye to Amy, who sang Bonnie Raitt last night, according to Simon she will be forgotten, and clearly he was right, as hard as that is for Amy and her fans to swallow...so Paul and Amy are the first two off in Season Six...Fantasia is performing in a few...We'll be back!

VOTE Night! Who's Headed Home...

Well, it is time to say farewell to four contestants on American Idol, and although we barely got to know them, we may all be better off with them gone....(kidding)...you have my predictions, and there will be a podcast tomorrow morning, pending my voice holds up.
Just before getting though the return of the dreaded Group sing, it was announced there would be an interesubt list of vocal coaches this season....including Diana Ross, Jon Bon Jovi, Tony Bennett, Barry Gibb and Gwen Stefani to name a few...I'm not looking forward to Gwen Stefani night...not very Cool even though she's Just a Girl, Underneath it All...I definitely won't Holla Back....ok enough of that...
Who's Headed Home..back in a few

The Gospel of Lakisha, Is No Man Worthy?

Tonight was a great evening for Idol…some of the women played it totally safe and it showed, much like it did last night for the guys. However in this game, there is no Immunity Idol, there are no cases to open, no life lines, no phone a friends, and no mob. The American people tonight, if they stayed up late enough may have heard the voice of the next American Idol. Lakisha, a single mom from Michigan, swept the stage with a ninety second performance that had it all. She knocked out in one shot the majority of the remaining 23 contestants, or at least let them know they will have to raise their game…GUYS, I hope you are listening. I realize its a long season for Idol, and any week you can be on your game and the next your not. Many of last nights performances, with the exception of a few will be forgotten. Tonights show will be remembered for Stephanie, Lakisha and all of whom proved they belonged on that stage tonight. Some of the other girls were almost there, but need to step up their game. I’, not saying or even crowning her the winner in Week 1, that would be insane, but as Simon said..the gauntlet was thrown down tonight. For four hopefuls the mic will go dark. Rudy, Saraya and Sundance are my three marked. One will be saved and he better remember this moment. I’m hoping Sundance gets another shot. He has a great voice.

As for the women, there’s 11 that could and can go home…J ..There were a few that stood out as being not up to par…among them, Antonella, Leslie, Alaina, Haley, and Philly girl Nicole…some had poor song choice, others seemed nervous..Alaina and Antonella are my choices. Sometimes the judges can be completely wrong with things.

There is a front runner, that is clear, right now she holds the title, but it’s early and there are plenty of rounds to go for, at the moment, any of 20 people, after tomorrow to close in on her.

Idol 2007, Top 12 Women(6-12)

Guys look relaxed, but they shouldn’t be…Philly girl Nicole Tranquillo up next.

Nicole Tranquillo…she’s got an interesting voice. “Stay Together” good stage presence, good song selection, great range. Randy: didn’t work for him. Paula: doesn’t know many people that can hit the notes that she hit…she can sing. Simon: Indulgent, aggressive, looked fake…so let me get this right…she goes, she SINGS, takes a risk and gets.. not much for it…WHAT? This is a SINGING competition, right? Randy said it was too urban…she has the chops…needs to get the right song to show them off…

Haley Scarnato, 24 up next…she has been a freelance singer since she was fifteen and considers Celene Dion her hero…here’s a shock..she’s doing a Celene Dion song…I’m gonna go out on a limb and say she is too gimmicky before I even hear her and she will be sent home this week…ok, just kidding. “All Coming Back to Me”…solid start, good stage presence, nice note toward the bridge, seems safe to me, played well to the camera too..did a nice job…Judges: Randy: ok for him, good choice though didn’t do anything special with it. Paula: did a nice job. Simon: Sounded 40, a bit like being at a reasonable good hotel and that was the last song of the evening. Made herself dated and old. A little boring…I disagree with the judges, however Celene’s radioplay days are well behind her, but she is an inspiration for a lot of people with her music. If Simon’s comments ring true, Mom’s and Grandmom’s should bring her back next week.

A quick recap of the evening- Stephanie is still the one to beat in my eyes, with Sabrina in a close second. Again tonight some are not picking the right songs for their very talented vocal chords. eight down, four to go…

Melinda Doolittle next..with the third Aretha song of the night. She is backup singer on stage and in the studio…great stage presence, she’s owning the stage, great personality, solid range..”Since You Been Gone”..she totally took an Aretha song and made it her own, no nerves..none that I noticed anyway..and she’s having fun! Judges: Randy: If you got it, show it, loved it! Paula: She’s a frontrunner, unbelieveable Simon: Incredible singer, fantastic person, really hope she does well. She’s in the top three tonight, she may even be the best I’ve heard to far….but there are three to go tonight.

Alaina Alexander, loves Mariah Carey and almost gave up her dream in music until she made it on Idol. “Brass in Pocket”…well she’s definitely putting her personality, like her voice, minimal nerves if any…and another one having some fun on the stage.

Judges: Randy: didn’t like the song, pitchy Paula: didn’t go for it and put her umph into it Simon: kept singing I’m Special and it wasn’t. hard to make that kind of song your own. Reliant on looks, not voice. Not sure she will be back next week…

Gina Glocksen, Dental assistant, she was one of the few who made it to Hollywood last year, and came back, to get past that round to the Top 24…”All By Myself”..ballad alert!

Ricky and the band keeping it low, pitchy on one of the high notes, managed to work it out…took the end cold, but will it payoff? Judges: Randy: surprised Paula: right song to sing. Simon: different side to her..didn’t think she hit the big note…however she has the mom in tears factor….we’ll see…

Lakisha Jones closing the show, she was tabbed as one of the best and she is closing the show…She’s from Michigan, and a single Mom…lets see what she’s got..

“Your Gonna Love Me”…great stage presence…personality, she’s closing with a bang…great notes on the end…cold too! We have a new frontrunner Judges: Randy: You laid it out…Paula: This is where you belong Simon: That’s the right note…very tempted to say to 23 people, book your plane tix home…was in a different league…Lakisha is the one to beat as of this moment…the guys have a LOT of work to do…some have a LOT LOT of work to do…and one or two of the guys can go home tonight…the review of the evening coming in a bit…

Idol 2007, Top 12 Women(1-6)

Alright, here we go…Top 12 Women…I’m thinking…gut feeling…that things are gonna be better than last night, could be a lot, could be a little, however there were more women than men from day one that tried out. No point in discussing the recaps and hooplah so we’ll get things started with the first song…

Stephanie Edwards…she’s sung at the Apollo Theatre and has won every singing contest she has ever entered….will Idol be next? Song choice tonight should be good, I hope better than last night…little soulful..great song..she’s showing off some personality, “How Come You Don’t Call Me”…she has some great stage presence and control..she’s blown last night away on her own….great high at the end…..WOW! Judges: they all LOVED it…Simon: Millon Times better than last night…which wasn’t going to be really hard to do…

Amy Krebs up next..she has been singing since she was a child….22 now, and went to a very esteemed Academy in NYC. Slow song for Amy, some Bonnie Raitt, tad pitchy but okay, she managed to pull through at the end…may not have been the best song choice for her. Judges: Randy: boring song and safe, too safe and I agree…Paula: agreed with Randy. Simon: cant remember her, personality of a candle, nothing to remember, like a thing that sings and two singers later he’s going to forget her. Amy clearly needs to step up her game, if she returns next week. She has a great personality.

Leslie Hunt is next. She’s a dog walker, as supposed to a dawg walker…sorry had to..from L.A….”You Make Me Feel”…started a tad slow…backup singers are drowning her out, not her fault…showed some bluesy quality, she too has stage presence, nice note at the end..not bad…Judges: Randy, not greatness, to big for her…I didn’t see it. Paula: She did a great job, but told her about song choice…Simon: Very nice girl and a dog walker…out of her comfort zone and looks embarrassed..I didn’t see that at all…again, butterflies…she has a very unique voice, I hope she continues she as a wow factor with her voice.

Sabrina Sloan up next..worked with the touring production of Hairspray. Quite the eclectic mix of people this year on Idol…they’ve done a little bit of everything. I think we have a competition on our hands…Sabrina is on every note, great stage presence, she’s got it going on…it’s a Wow from me…great performance. Randy: We have a competition. Paula: standing ovation Simon: proved the point in taking part and have a desire to win with talent, best performance so far…I totally agree…great poise, amazing performance.

Antonella Barba from Point Pleasant, New Jersey…so a Jersey girl and a Philly girl in the competition this year. J She began singing in sixth grade and has done some traveling with it…ballad…Aerosmith…she put her personality into it, another great arrangement from Ricky and the band…she made it her own…pretty good stage presence too. Judges: Randy didn’t like it, was a tad pitchy. Paula: took the you look beautiful road Simon: thought the song was too big and thinks her chances of remaining have been damaged..I totally disagree, I thought she was pitchy but her range was great. She took a risk and fell flat with the judges, but they don’t decide the winner.

Well we’re almost half way through and we have a competition on the girls side and I’m sure the guys will take note. Three stand out..Antonella, I disagree with the judges, Sabrina, and Stephanie.

Jordan Sparks, the youngen, 17 up next. She began singing at eighteen months, and is from Arizona. Performing Tracy Chapman…way too much reverb on her mic…sounds like she is having all kinds of problems…tried to make it her own, pulled it together at the end, but is it enough? Judges: Randy: not being challenging enough Paula: great selection, came into her own, it was fun Simon: seen a big change with you, typical sweet, good voice. Simon suggested she push herself…not sure what they heard in the studio but the first half of that seemed off to me. Ok first half done…be back with the remaining six….you got it…After The Break…

Idol 2007, Ladies...Please...

Ooops, that’s from another show…lets hope the women can belt some notes tonight, I glanced at Ken’s blog from USA today and tonight we’ll hear a few Aretha Tunes and Alicia Keys among others…Well get things going in about fifteen…after the break and all of the montage stuff….See ya then..

First Night Wrapup: Safe Songs and Visions of Teletubbies...

First off, a key word of the evening..SAFE...everyone played it SAFE...there were a few performances on the fringes, but overall the night was a little blah...with a few one liners from Simon and crew and some well placed lyrical high notes that were hit very well. We saw Saraya fight back against Simon, for which he deserves credit, although he needs to work on his performance chops for next week, if he returns and isn't in the bottom two...the great part about Idol at this point of the season is that a blah performance this week has a pretty good chance of returning next week to rebound nicely, such the case for Mr. Festivus himself, Sundance - I would love to say his name in this blog for a few more weeks at least, considering other sources, including the judges deemed him worthy of being in the Top 3 or 4 of this years crop. Bad song choices were the theme of the night, although I'm not sure any producer would admit to it..The two I have mentioned above are my bottom two for the week.Overall I caught myself yawning a few time last night about an hour in...it wasn't the shock I expected from the first night of Idol...instead of being Wow'd by anyone, with the exception of a few performances that were okay, I was practically sleep typing. What would be awesome is if the women, which had a larger group from the beginning this year, blew away the guys and brought down every house in America tonight with their performances. After last night, unless things change, I think it is pretty safe to say that the next Idol will not be a guy...Catch you back tomorrow night...

Idol 2007, Top 12 Men(7-12)

Into the second hour and no real standouts yet in this years Top 12 class…as far as the men go…

Blake Lewis…the spikey beatbox guy….”Somewhere OnlyWe Know”…like the look, clean cut, again what is it…SAFE, it’s SAFE…his parents can’t even get into it…seemed very bland to me personally…Judges: Randy…”dug” it…Paula: picked an odd song, said he was cool and contemporary..Simon: first to sound like 2007…Keane was spot on for me personally, best ORIGINAL performance tonight….if you can say that about Idol…Sanjaya, the 17 year old who comes from a school of singers, “after the break”…

Sanjaya, “Something About Your Love”…vocal was alright, seemed very boring…”bore you with it” are the lyrics and I was bored….range was okay…Judges: Randy and Paula: said not good…Paula looking for more personality. Simon: picked up on my lyrical quip…Sunjaya will be in the final four Wednesday night….sorry to say…Chris Sly coming up…

Chris Sligh, one of a few guys this year who has traveled and performed with a band. ..finally someone who picks a tune that matches their voice…loved the arrangement..”Typical”….nice close, was on his notes….but will David Hasselhoff cry?...Judges: Paula, Randy – liked the performance. Simon: Felt I was at a weird student gig…he’s safe..looking forward to next week..

Jared Cotter, (not a teletubby)..next…”Back At One”…Brian McKnight…another good vocal pick..did a nice job..falsetto was okay…Judges: Randy: alright Paula: likes the more uptempo stuff, and the Teletubby: Unadventurous, nasally. He’ll be safe…Simon added that he needs to take more risks..I agree…again, it’s a SAFE night…AJ next..

AJ Tabaldo…works for a shipping company…”Never Too Much”..nice with the uptempo, vocal was okay, falsetto was okay..again didn’t blow me away. Paula says he can sing, and he can, he’s got the chops, needs to shake the butterflies..he’s the darkhorse this year for the guys in the eyes of this radio dj…he can wow a lot of votes..did they save the best for last? Phil Stacey….the navy singer and father of two…next

Phil Stacey…”I Could Not Ask For More”…shaky start, but picked it up with the bridge…Wow….not WOW! But Wow…one of the better ninety seconds of the night…Judges: Randy, loved the vocal, as did Paula…Simon: okay at the end…

Final wrap of the evening in a bit…it was a great vocal one he got going…great range, Phil shook off the butterflies the best out of the Top 12 Men….be back in a bit…